Pellet Grill Newbie

benhood

New member
Joined
Dec 27, 2024
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Location
Gunter, TX
Grill
Searwood XL 600
User name is basically my name. I live in Gunter, TX (Go Tigers) - north of the Dallas Ft Worth Metroplex. Was searching for a place to learn of recipes, tips, etc as I am a brand new owner of the Weber Searwood XL 600. Never owned a pellet grill/smoker before. Never operated one either. Son-in-law has a Recteq and loves it. Although I work in the IT field, my passion is hunting/fishing and cooking. I have been cooking/baking/drying/canning since I was in grade school (over 50 years ago) and have had the fortune to have great friends who were top chefs in their careers. So learned a lot from those guys. Smoking and bbq'ng foods, cooking on my grills is just comforting to me. Currently I have a Big Green Egg, a Blackstone griddle, a Old Country Brazos stick burner offset and a Solo Stove Pi Prime pizza oven (I love pizza and make it all the time). What led me to stepping into the Pellet smoker/grill world basically comes down to time. When it comes to doing long cooks, it has become harder to dedicate a day - 2 days of almost constant attention. Thus, I feel like the Pellet smoker can afford me the time to still do long cooks without needing to "be on call constantly" to the cooking device. I still love my offset and think it is hard to beat on a brisket or pork butt for that famous taste, but I think the challenge of almost matching that on the Searwood is going to be fun. Seen lots of folks very satisfied with the results they've gotten. Plus I just like variety and trying new things. My grown kids are into this cooking/bbq'ng thing as well - they all have kamado's / blackstones / or pellet grills and they all do really well with the dishes they prepare from those devices. It's a family thing and lots of fun.
 
Congrats on the new Searwood and welcome to the forum @benhood 🍻

Let us know how the first smoke goes with it!
 
Sounds like you are a bit of a renaissance man, and always staying curious. I have the Weber SmokeFire EX6 Gen2 for about three years now. I have been fortunate with mine, but very interested in how the Searwood will do. That being said here are a couple of tips on a pellet smoker I have found to maximize smoke flavor, bark formation, and keeping moisture in the meat.

1. The Pellet Matters: not all pellets are made the same. I have found two types of pellets I use now. One for grilling and one for long slow cooks. I have even blended them. Since your Searwood can get up to 600 degrees I would recommend Royal Oak Charcoal Pellets for grilling. They burn longer, hotter, and are weather resistant (humidity) than wood pellets. They are also cheap. If using wood pellets you will burn through more than charcoal ones. I would imagine they would be great for Manual Mode. For the long and slow cooks I prefer Smokin Pecan SHELL Pellets. They are more expensive than other wood pellets, but they also burn longer and produce the most smoke than any wood pellet I have tried. Not by a little but by a lot. And like I mentioned I also blend the two together for grilling.

2. Use the second shelf for long and slow cooks with a water pan underneath. I have found the water pan does three distinct things for the pellet grill. One it adds needed moisture in the cook chamber. Since all pellet grills use a fan the air circulates and reduces moisture in the chamber. The water pan will help to counter it. Second it will catch the drippings from the meat. Helps tremendously with clean up. And lastly since water boils around 212 degrees the water pan will act as a heat sync stabilizing the cook chamber's temperature. Especially if you prefer to spritz the meat and open & close the lid.

3. Use cold meat (straight out of the refrigerator) when you start, and put the pellet grill to 180 - 200 degrees (smoke boost) until the meat reaches the internal temperature of 140 degrees. Since pellet grills do not produce smoke like the stick burners, this will help to capture the most smoke flavor in the meat. And since meat will stop absorbing smoke flavor into the meat around the 140 internal temperature, putting the cold meat on will extend its exposure to the smoke longer. It does add to the cook time, but it does help. Once the meat reaches an internal temperature of 140, you can increase the pellet grill's temperature to start to really render the fat and finish the cooking process.

4. Foil Boat: this step I have found really helps the meat (brisket/pork butt) in many ways on the pellet grill. One it allows for the bark to be continued to develop and capture smoke flavor. It also allows the meat to cook in its own fat (confit style). Now I use to wait to foil boat once the meat pushed through the stall, but now I foil boat right after the meat reaches the 140 internal temperature. Yes you will have to most likely dump some of the render fat/juices, but this is another reason for have the water pan underneath the meat. By using the foil boat right when the meat reaches the 140 internal degrees I have found the meat retains more moisture at the end of the cook. Especially with brisket in the flat area. It will protect the edges also during the cook allowing you to raise the pellet grill's temperature up to 300 degrees to really get the sugar cookie bark on top.

5. Spritzing and Probing : since the meat is in a foil boat, you can continue to spritz the meat keeping it moist on top. Smoke will attach better to moist meat than dry meat. Another technique needed in a pellet grill to capture as much smoke flavor as possible. And since the top of the meat is open because of the foil boat you can easily check the temperature with a probe or instant thermometer.

If I follow these steps using my pellet grill I typically get results most people say comes very close to a stick burner for smoke flavor. It is unfortunate you have to apply so many techniques to get the most smoke flavor, but I do not think they add too much headache. Hopes this helps.
 
Thank you for these tips. I am learning quite a bit. Found an old brisket in my deep freezer the other day and experimented with that. But that old brisket must have been bad (didn't smell bad) but the taste was terrible. I didn't do a boat but just wrapped in butcher paper. It looked amazing, was tender and all but wife and I just couldn't eat it. Was using a 50/50 mix of Bear Mountain Oak and Hickory. So thinking that brisket must have freezer burned or something (prob 3 or 4 yrs old). Otherwise, did a pork tenderloin and a Mississippi Pot roast (chuck roast) and those tasted great. Also did a bar style thin crust pizza on a steel plate and that did great too. I will follow your recommendations regarding the foil boat, water pan, low temp to 140 and all. Like the idea of those Royal Oak charcoal pellets for high temp grilling (high temp devours pellets and don't want to waste my smoking pellets!). And will go buy a fresh new brisket!! Just to prove it aint the smoker!!!
 
Yeah, I had the idea of using timed amounts of pellets in my Searwood 600 for cooks. When I did my ribs a week ago, I started off with Bear Mountain Gourmet BBQ blend (about $18/20-lb bag) pellets for the first 3-hour period to produce a good smoke and flavor. After that 3 hours, however, I had to wrap the ribs in paper. No point in good smoke there - I just need fuel to burn. So I added cheap Pit Boss Hickory pellets (about $10/20-lb bag) just to burn.

This is a recurring theme with long and slow cooks. Only the first 2-3 hours are worth smoking anyway. After that, you gotta turn the heat up a bit to render the meat and fat anyway. No point even wasting your GOOD pellets doing that. So to save money in the long run, that's what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna have my good pellets for the initial smoke, then cheap pellets to simply burn after.

Also, I've been watching people on YT who are experimenting with mixing small wood chips in with their pellets to try to get more smoke. Seems like an interesting idea, but could damage cheaper made screw augers. I've also seen augur damage from the charcoal pellets since they're a lot harder to break apart and sheer forces aren't that great from those little augur motors.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Latest Discussions

Back
Top